Jamie's relationship with his family has always been rocky and learning that he was adopted only made things more complicated. Is Daisy Jones & The Six Based on a True Story? However, Evelyns death changed the character in a big way. Hence, it is likely that John's mother never recovered from losing her younger son. Yellowstone centers around the Dutton family, the owners of the largest ranch in the United States. Spencer Dutton was separated from his new wife Alexandra after her former fianc forced him into a fatal duel on Sunday's episode of 1923 on the Paramount+ service. John Dutton III's brother died as an infant. Some of the show's stars have admitted that even they are confused by the characters' relationships (and we suspect Taylor Sheridan is being intentionally cryptic about some of the connections), but fear not: We're here to clear up some of the confusion with the Dutton family tree. As the story behind his birth mother has been a guarded secret, many have some inventive ideas about the truth of Jamie's maternity. Jamie even introduces him to his child and his childs mother, Christina. He's married to Emma and they have a son, Jack. While the series heavily explores Johns relationship with his children, it does not dive much into Johns relationship with his own parents. Theory: Jamie Dutton's birth mother is a Dutton John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamie's birth father. Its like a part of her soul just left when her mother died. Now, Kevin Costner is reflecting on Johns perspective on the bombshell and John and Jamies relationship. ADVERTISEMENT The Duttons adopted Jamie when he was only three months old and raised him as their own. Yellowstone's latest episode revealed what happened between Beth Dutton and her brother Jamie. This complete list includes 1883 and 1923. When Beth Dutton first appears on "Yellowstone," there's no build-up to her cutthroat tactics; she's vengeful from the onset. After Season 3 finishes airing, this falls premieres will arrive to keep fans busy entertained as they wait for Season 4. Jamie came from a more troubling family that had their own secrets. The character is also seen during flashback scenes in season 4 of Yellowstone. Why Did John Dutton Adopt Jamie? Jamie still reminds John of his sister and the pain she caused the family so John maintains a bit of resentment. John raised Jamie as his own but he is not his biological father. However, John's story doesn't have a happy ending, as he is killed early . My ONLY question is this: wouldnt John have mentioned this to Jamie during their conversation about his adoption? Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. This isnt a monarchy being passed down to the heir. John Dutton figures she has killed her brother. of appearances 43 First appearance Daybreak - season 1, episode 1 James Michael "Jamie" Dutton is a Yellowstone character played by Wes Bentley. Surprise parents and long-guarded secrets are tropes often found on television. You can unsubscribe at any time. In season three, John reveals that he knew Jamie's mother Phyllis before she married Garrett Randall. Hes probably got more optimism maybe in a sense until the death of his wife just shatters him and I think hardens him to a point that he stops caring. Despite the tragic loss, John does eventually begin seeing Governor Lynelle Perry later in life. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The Duttons were a prominent family in the area, known for giving second chances to people who need them. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. My personal opinion is that John may be blinded in some ways concerning how he has genuinely treated Jamie. (Like, does Jamie actually descend from Spencer's line and John has tried to screw him out of a rightful inheritance? Powered by WordPress.com VIP. Jamie Duttons real parents are Garrett and Phyllis Randall, and originally Jamie went by the name Michael Randall. You know, when they try it themselves. She was addicted to drugs (not far from Beths problems with alcohol), ran off with Garrett Randall, was disowned by Johns father, and eventually murdered by Garrett. Question what you do and who you are. But there is a war being waged against our way of life. After learning the truth about his heritage, Jamie meets Garrett. I like it, but I think you are close. Season 1, Episode 1 of Yellowstone captured the tragic death of John Dutton's oldest son, Lee (Dave Annable). However, John does not mention his mothers name, and the character remains unnamed after several seasons. John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamies birth father. I do the very best I can for my children and if they want to tell me someday why I wasn't a great father, I guess I'll listen, but you know lots of luck to them. Kayce is married to Monica Long (Kelsey Asbille). In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Brandon Sklenar, the actor who portrays Spencer, said he's unsure how Spencer is related to Kevin Costner's John Dutton III: "Its something that Taylor [Sheridan] is keeping very close to the vest. Flashbacks have revealed that Evelyn was not the gentlest mother, after all, and the depth of her bond with Jamie is as yet unclear. Trending SR Exclusives Star Wars Marvel DC Star Trek The Last of Us The Mandalorian. Jamie Dutton was adopted as a baby by John and Evelyn Dutton. The Yellowstone Theory About Jamie's Birth Mother Would Complicate Things Even More. The character is also seen during flashback scenes in season 4 of Yellowstone. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. He is one of at least three John's in the family, the others being his son, John Dutton Jr., and his grandson, John Dutton III. I have my own theories, but its to be told, to be written, to be seen. Jamie killed the reporter he had done the tell-all interview with about John to squash its release after she refused. That is progress in today's terms, so if it's progress you seek, do not vote for me. Emma (Marley Shelton) was the wife of John Dutton Sr. and mother of Jack Dutton in 1923. After she wouldnt budge, he decided the only way out was to k*ll his father himself. Beth married longtime love Rip Wheeler in an unconventional ceremony in season 4. Garrett became overwhelmed with anger that Jamie was put in such a dangerous situation. Beth gives Jamie three options: she would report both Jamie and Garrett to the police, she would tell Rip that Garrett tried to k*ll her or Jamie himself could k*ll Garrett. "John also told Jamie that he begged Jamie's birth mother not to marry Garrett Randall because John knew what kind of man Garrett was. By John Connor Coulston - August 1, 2018 10:33 pm EDT. We get to see this very pure young girl go through such a trauma, Reilly said in an interview. Heres how it works. It's also presumed that he's the grandfather of John Dutton III (aka, Yellowstone's main character). As production for Yellowstones next outing continues in Montana, fans took to Reddit to discuss further possibilities for Jamie when the show returns. It really would be a coincidence that Jamie got the name Jamie though but it also makes sense that it would be Evelyn's sister as the mother. That impacts how John sees and treats Jamie. He stepped down from his position at the request of Governor Lynelle Perry and his son, Kayce Dutton, was named the new Livestock Commissioner. He's married to Margaret, and they have three children: Elsa, Spencer, and John Dutton Sr. John Dutton Sr. (James Badge Dale) is the namesake of Yellowstone's John Dutton and is the second child of James and Margaret. After coming home from work one day, Garrett was horrified to discover young Jamie crying and sucking on a crack pipe. I think it was Johns sister in law. With John Dutton (Kevin Costner) opting to speak fairly little about his mother, viewers must be wondering about her identity and fate. And as if his life isn't tragic enough, now fans on Reddit are even theorizing what the next bombshell will be for the forgotten son. Though she did not succumb immediately, Evelyn died within a few hours.[1]. Distant son Jamie Dutton was devastated to discover his true origins in the latest season of Yellowstone. The Real Housewives of Atlanta The Bachelor Sister Wives 90 Day Fiance Wife Swap The Amazing Race Australia Married at First Sight The Real Housewives of Dallas My 600-lb Life Last Week Tonight with John Oliver. Jamie's biological father beat Jamie's biological mother to death when Jamie was three-months-old. Thats all I can say. Evelyn appears in the. Josh Lucas, who plays a young John Dutton in Yellowstone, talks about the impact of Evelyns death on his character. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Lee Dutton was shot by Robert Long in Season 1 of 'Yellowstone.'. Perhaps, that had to do with Jamie going above and criminally beyond to correct his course. Claire (Dawn Olivieri) and her daughter Mary Abel join James and his family on their journey, but their story meets a tragic and brutal end. Yellowstone patriarch John Dutton (Kevin Costner) finally came clean about the rift between himself and son Kayce (Luke Grimes) on . John Dutton III is a main character on Yellowstone. However, the narrative does not touch upon Johns relationship with his mother. You will receive a verification email shortly. James/Jamie Randall was the birth name given to the current Jamie Dutton. John recently learned that Jamie gave the okay for an unwitting Bet to undergo a hysterectomy as part of getting an abortion as a teen. Evelyn may have convinced John to take Jamie in because he is family and continues to care for him to honor his wife. I have to say, Ive never been convinced but you do a great job of making it highly plausible, esp. I also think Evelyn (Johns wife) is the one who wanted to do it. Albeit Yellowstone did see John hold back from hurting Jamie after the reveal about what he did to Beth. I am sure that John believes that in his heart, but his eyes should tell him another story. I find it so interesting we know nothing about John Dutton III's mother. When Jamie was three months old, John and Evelyn Dutton adopted him. [SPOILERS AHEAD: If you're not caught up on all three shows, proceed with caution.]. Please refresh the page and try again. Kevin Costner's John Dutton is the most famous of the family patriarchs who now serves as governor of Montana. Phyllis Mary Randall was Phyllis Mary Dutton, John's sister." Jamie will find out he actually is a Dutton through his mother, John is is uncle, and john deserves to be called dad because he raised him. A big reveal thats simple enough for any degree of watcher to pick up on. But, you do bring up something I totally spaced on: if she was a blood tie to John, or even Evelyn, why no trip to the train station? One fan elaborated: I dont think she was related to them in any way, I just think because it was a small town they all knew each other and she was a friend of the family. However, things go south when Jamie learns his father is behind the attacks on Beth, John and Kayce in season three. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Both Kayce and Beth witnessed the death of their mother, but Beth carries the guilt of blaming herself for what happened. Elizabeth (Michelle Randolph) appears in 1923 as the fianc to Jack. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. I still think that Jamie has no blood relation to the Duttons. I do think potentially that his mother worked on the ranch and that bio dad may have been a ranch hand and therefore the Duttons felt some responsibility for taking him in. Does John Dutton Have Siblings? Jamie was born as James Michael Randall to a couple named Garrett Randall and Phyllis Mary Randall , who had quite a rough marriage. The two were set to be married before she was injured in the ambush by the sheep farmers that also killed her father. This leads to remorse and acceptance back into the Yellowstone crew for the cycle to start over again with a different character. There was a problem. Jamie's biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. His wife, Evelyn, passed away before the Yellowstone story began, and together they had Kayce, Beth, and Lee (who also died). Screen Rant. John reveals to Jamie in season three of Yellowstone that he knew his mother,Phyllis, before she married Garrett Randall. . It's unclear if John and Emma are also the parents of John Jr. James Badge Dale admitted to TV Insider that he's not sure how his character is related to John Jr. and therefore John III (Kevin Costner): "I have no idea. Moreover, she could have been related to Johns late wife Evelyn (Gretchen Mol), who was shown to have been crushed by a horse during a tragic flashback in the first season. After tragedy, Elizabeth and Jack recite their vows to each other, and Elizabeth confides in Cara that she is pregnant. Jack is a common nickname for John, so some fans speculate that he is actually John Jr., but that has not been revealed. His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. Little is mentioned about Evelyn initially, however the events surrounding her death slowly come to light. The series is rich in lore as the episodes, and spin-off shows slowly explore the past of the historic ranch and the family members who are a part of the lands history. Not Together Anymore? SPOILERS AHEAD! They havent said yet, so right now its anyones guess. He is a former soldier-turned-big game hunter who is called home from Africa to help his family defend their land. good points on the name/Rip counter. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, The main character in the story is named John Dutton. Similar to how Beth took in Carter and Rip had to deal with it, that is how Everlyn went about Jamie. If the Dutton side ends up being true these quotes could be a result of John being stubborn, and hardened against his degenerate sister and murderer husband. a formerly convicted criminal responsible for the death of Jamie's birth mother, Phyllis, while the two were addicted to drugs. Yellowstone season 4's ending lights many fuses. When viewers meet her husband, John Dutton Jr, she appears to have passed away. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. well let's see how Sheridan went about it. I think there is going to be some "twist" regarding both John's parentage and Jamie's mother. For his part, Jamie seemed somewhat swayed by Johns impassioned speech. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. The show seems to use Johns gruff, contemplative, and short winded nature as a plot device to withhold important information. Actor Patton has. John Dutton Sr., originally known as John Dutton, is a main character in 1883: A Yellowstone Origin Story. Redditor Luvsplants123 posted: So who do you think Jamie's real mother is? His intentions might have been there, but I do not think he has been as forgiving of Jamie as he has Kayce. John loved his wife and her wishes to adopt him. In the fourth episode of season 4, John explains that his mother took Peter's death to heart. In one episode, Beth bathes in a trough and drinks champagne on the anniversary of her mothers death. And with the ever-expanding cast of characters, it can be hard to keep up with how each one is related. After meeting his estranged biological father, some fans of the Paramount Western are convinced his journey of self-discovery is far from over. Kerry is an English actress, who played Ishay, Doc Cottle's subordinate on Battlestar Galactica.. With Jamies mind in a tailspin, and the fate of the rest of the family on tenterhooks after the season finale, fans are anticipating even more exhilarating twists and turns for season four. He made that connection official when he married Beth. How do you know Jamie was the name of the Dutton who built Yellowstone? Adopted son of John and Evelyn, Jamie (Wes Bentley) was raised as one of their own. In an outburst of fury, Garrett murdered Phyllis for putting Jamies life in danger. It would be nice if Yellowstone surprised with the adoption revelation bringing John and Jamie closer together. Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) is adopted. At the time Garrett is living on his own on a farm. I find it so interesting we know nothing about John Dutton III's mother. Free-spirited Alex ran away with Spencer in Africa. Played by Helen Mirren, Cara is another strong, independent woman in the Dutton family tree. His birth name was James(Jamie) Michael Randall. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. Actor Kelly Reilly discussed the impact that Evelyns death had on her character, Beth. Fans of the first "Yellowstone" origin series "1883" might recall that Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) was married to Comanche tribesman Sam (Martin Sensmeier), who she met while heading toward Montana . As that period Western spinoff began, the Dutton family which consists of James, Margaret, and their children Elsa (Isabel May) and John (Audie Rick) are planning to move their family north. Read More: Does John Dutton Have Siblings? Article continues below advertisement. Paramount Networks Yellowstone follows the Duttons, a family of ranchers who have operated the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch for generations. My world was shaken up and how I dealt with things, I'm sure I dealt with him the same, but probably things started to bleed in. Josh Holloway salary: How much is Josh Holloway paid for Yellowstone. The character has appeared as an older man in Yellowstone, and he is presumed to be the son of John Sr. and father of John III. He buried Evelyn on the ranch. It doesn't mean I didnt feel different, but I made a conscious effort to give him the same love and attention that his brother and sister did, and that had to do with my wife. While there is not a lot we know about Phyllis and how she knew the Duttons, many fans have their theories. After doing that on Yellowstone, John said that Jamie could have killed himself instead of Sarah to right things. She's a strong woman and mother of three (Elsa, Spencer, and John) who joins James in their perilous journey west, eventually settling in Montana. (@wesbentleyfanpage) "When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it because we knew," said John in season . Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. John Sr.'s wife Emma (Marley Shelton) has one son that we know of: Jack. Cookies help us deliver our Services. John sees in Jamie the man who took his sister from the family and then murdered her. He said he loves his adopted son even though he has been "a disappointment and my greatest failure." Has Beth killed him? Christina is aware that Jamie has cut the Duttons out of his life and is making his own decisions now. Another's been married 32 years and a third loves quilting - as the superstar, 64, unveils her SIXTH boytoy . However, Kevin Costners John Dutton is the Dutton familys present patriarch. Jamies biological father killed his biological mother when Jamie was three-months-old, and after he went to prison for second-degree murder, Evelyn and John Dutton adopted Jamie. I propose that Jamies mothers maiden name was Dutton. Sunday, 5th March 2023See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. Rips story and position on the ranch should prove that Jamie is more than just an adopted son of a deadbeat. How it's immoral that you live here,work here, grow their food here. You covered everything." At the end of Episode 4, Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) finds out to his shock that Riggins' former cellmate in prison is Jamie's own biological father, Garrett Randall (Will Patton), with whom. Yellowstone occasionally features flashbacks to the '90s, showing John Dutton and his wife Evelyn with their kids, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. The latest story, 1923, debuted on Paramount+ on December 18 and wasted no time in revealing what happened to the lead characters in 1883, James and Margaret Dutton. Beth (Kelly Reilly) is the only daughter of the Dutton family, and she helps run the family's business operations. I like the theory. Jamies father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. In 1997, Evelyn went out to ride horses with a young Beth and Kayce. John was married to Evelyn before she suffered a tragic fate and they share four kids: Lee, Beth, Kayce, and Jamie. It's not the first time it's happened on the hit Taylor Sheridan -created neo-Western saga, but the operatic feud between Dutton siblings Beth, played by Kelly Reilly, and Jamie, played by Wes . Though some fans had follow-up thoughts, no one can deny that this would be information that would blow up Jamie's life. We are led to believe that John takes boys in because of Rip but in this instance, Jamie is adopted and given the Dutton name. She seems to have been especially hard on Beth. Luke Grimes Teases Kayce's 'Yellowstone' Season 4 Journey. Mary Abel (Emma Malouff) is Claire's last surviving child, until she too meets her demise in 1883. On March 30, 1997, she was out riding with two of their children, and her horse was spooked which caused it to fall over, causing her to experience a Spinal Injury and significant internal bleeding. I propose that Jamie's mother's maiden name was Dutton. How different would Johns reaction have been if Evelyn Dutton were still alive? "It seems odd that a couple with the social standing of the Duttons would be that closely involved with simply a casual neighbor or friend." Other fans chimed in to agree. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. A flashback to 1997 shows Evelyn went riding with two of her children, Beth and Kayce. In Season 1, after local Native American chief Thomas Rainwater (Gil Birmingham) threatens to start a land war with the Duttons, Beth promises her father, John (Kevin Costner), that she'll keep the Yellowstone ranch in the Dutton family no matter the cost. This is America. Phyllis Mary Randall was Phyllis Mary Dutton, Johns sister. The series follows the lives of the Dutton family members who seek to protect their ancestral ranch . Spoilers for Season 3, Episode 7 of Yellowstone entitled The Beating are discussed below. He confronts his father about the topic and eventually meets his biological father as he discovers who he really is. U/Matthmil hypothesized the story behind Jamie's mother is similar and that his birth mother is quite possibly a Dutton herself. His son Lee Dutton died in a shootout in season one. . He married and started a family with Evelyn Dutton. Fan-favorite Rip (Cole Hauser) is the manager of the Dutton ranch and has been an unofficial member of the family since his teenage years. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamies birth mother well before Jamie was born. This leads to other characters making logical decisions based on the information they have but those decisions are terrible and creates a lot of drama for the characters. He owns one of the biggest cattle ranches of the United States. He is the former Livestock Commissioner for the state of Montana and one of the most respected, powerful members of the communities from Bozeman to Livingston. Its land. "The Yellowstone ain't a ranch, it's an empire," Garrett tells . On how John handled parenting Jamie, Kevin Costner said: But he was supported and Jamie's manufactured that I had never liked him, that I was never good to him, that's something that he's made up. and Gil Birmingham, revolves around the life of John Dutton, the leader of America's largest contiguous ranch. Jamie and Garett Randalls Relationship Sam (Martin Sensmeier) is a Comanche warrior who encounters the Dutton family along their journey in 1883. We shall see Maybe Jamie is from John's wife's side (his sister in law? If John and Evelyn were not Jamie's birth parents, then his biological parents must be out there. Jamie, the son of cattle farm owner John Dutton and his partner Evelyn Dutton, is a lawyer in the show. Jamie's father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. His father was listed Garrett Randall and mother was Phyllis Mary Randall. I feel like that is a whole lane that can have secrets in . Who is John Dutton's parents? However, nothing could be done and Evelyn died soon after. I think you hit the nail on the head. Jamie Dutton is the name of the Dutton patriarch that first claimed the land and founded the Yellowstone ranch. Eventually, Garrett even moves in with Jamie at his new home. Both theories makes sense but the naming is too much of a coincidence. One day when Garrett found an . We also dont know Jamies mothers maiden name. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. Movies. So far in the series, Kayce's son, Tate, is John's only . In Evelyns dying moments, she looked at Beth and said, She did this. However, the show has not mentioned the exact reason for her death. I think the quotes are better evidence for the Evelyn family theory than the Dutton family theory but I dont think they rule out Jamies mother being a Dutton. Tate (Brecken Merrill) has grown up during the 5 seasons of Yellowstone, and he is the future of the Yellowstone ranch. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Garrett previously claimed that he killed Jamie's birth mother to protect Jamie, but Garrett and John's history seemed to simmer with all kinds .